Why your number one Google ranking is now almost worthless

David Nelkin explains how ranking number one on Google is no longer the best way to get potential patients hearing about your practice.

Recently in this column I argued that ranking number one on Google no longer means what most practice owners think it means. The results page now has so many separate areas that ‘number one’ doesn’t point to one thing.

That argument has gone from feeling slightly contrarian to fairly obvious.

So I want to push it a step further.

Even when a practice genuinely does rank number one in the traditional organic results, it can still be almost completely invisible in the answers patients are actually reading.

Those answers are increasingly coming from somewhere else.

There is no page two of an AI answer

Google’s intelligent search rollout is now here.

More and more patients are asking a question of an assistant rather than scanning a list of links, and the assistant gives them an answer.

That answer either mentions your practice or it doesn’t.

You are either part of the response or you are nowhere, because nobody scrolls through an AI answer hunting for the practice that came 10th.

This is happening on top of the shift I described last month, not instead of it.

The uncomfortable disconnect

The pages AI tools actually cite when they recommened a local business are largely not the pages winning the traditional results.

Reported overlap between Google’s top 10 and the sources AI answers pull from has been put as low as around 17 to 36%, depending on the query. One analysis found that roughly 90% of the pages ChatGPT cites sit at position 21 or lower in Google.

A practice can rank number one, with all the domain authority that implies, and still draw close to zero AI citations.

Everything it has ever published lives on its own website and nowhere else.

What Google AI is actually rewarding

The signal that increasingly decides whether an assistant puts a practice forward is not what we have understood for 20 years.

It is brand presence in all the places that are not your own website – reviews spread across platforms rather than just Google, best-of and ‘near me’ guides written by other people, industry articles, forum threads where real patients compare local options, videos on Youtube, Instagram and TikTok, mentions in publications.

Branded mentions across credible sources now look like a stronger predictor of being recommended by an AI than the levers most of the industry has been pulling for two decades.

The old internet ranked pages. The new one ranks reputations.

A reputation does not live on your own website. It lives in all the places other people are talking about you.

And if you are not in those places, the assistants making recommendations have no reason to put you forward.

Looking beyond number one

None of this means stop doing SEO. Strong traditional SEO is the floor here, not the ceiling.

The large majority of AI citations still come from sources that already perform well organically, so the fundamentals are the entry ticket rather than the prize.

What has changed is what sits on top of them.

The work that earns the recommendation now happens almost entirely off your own website, and that is where the strategic effort has to move.

The practices that grasp this and act on it will compound.

Xcelerator Dental is a specialist dental growth agency that helps practices grow through cross-channel marketing and helping them convert the leads they generate. Find out more at www.xceleratordental.com.

Follow Dentistry.co.uk on Instagram to keep up with all the latest dental news and trends.